CHIME Responds to Proposed Stage 2 Objectives, Seeks Assessment of Stage 1 Progress First
ANN ARBOR, MI, February 17, 2011 –The College of Healthcare Information Management Executives (CHIME) submitted its comments on the impending meaningful use Stage 2 objectives today, requesting that more time be allocated to enable assessment of Stage 1 progress and improved preparation for moving to Stage 2.
According to CHIME, meaningful use measures and objectives for Stage 2 should reflect the capabilities and experiences of hospitals and physicians to handle the scope of Stage 1 before any measures for the second stage are codified.
“CHIME believes that it would not be prudent to move to Stage 2 until about 30 percent of (eligible hospitals and eligible providers) have been able to demonstrate EHR MU under Stage 1,” the organization’s comment letter read. “We believe this approach would strike a reasonable balance between the desire to push EHR adoption and MU as quickly as possible, and the recognition that unreasonable expectations could end up discouraging EHR adoption if providers conclude that it will be essentially impossible for them to qualify for incentives.”
Providers may seek to qualify incentives by achieving meaningful use objectives for Stage 1 by September 30, 2012, but legislation establishing the EHR Incentive Program does not lay out hard-and-fast deadlines for initiating the second stage of the program, with its subsequent set of objectives.
CHIME’s comment letter also recommends that Stage 2 have a core and menu set structure similar to that used in Stage 1; core measures are required meaningful use objectives, while providers must select at least five objectives from the menu set. Under the CHIME proposal, core measures would be those already incorporated in Stage 1, with some measures increasing in compliance levels, while the menu set would be new measures introduced in Stage 2.
“Hospitals and physicians are going to continue to need flexibility as we enter Stage 2,” said Pamela McNutt, senior vice president and CIO of Dallas-based Methodist Health System and chair of CHIME’s Policy Steering Committee. “Measures being introduced for the first time should be part of a menu set to allow providers to focus on those that best match their operational goals.”
The comments from CHIME, an Ann Arbor, Mich.-based professional organization representing about 1,400 chief information officers and other top information technology executives at many of the nation’s largest hospitals, were submitted to the Health IT Policy Committee, which is collecting public remarks in forming Stage 2 meaningful use recommendations that it will present to the Dept. of Health and Human Services later this summer.
Delaying the move to Stage 2 also would give federal agencies more time to develop clear policies that are defined in advance, which would give time-pressed providers and vendors clear guidance that they need for the industry to implement clinical systems, meet meaningful use objectives, and qualify for stimulus funding.
“Although most CIOs take the lead in deploying and encouraging optimization of information systems, our primary goal is to help introduce and manage change in our organizations,” said David Muntz, chair of CHIME’s Advocacy Leadership Team. “The change management implications of our current environment have never been greater, hence, our interest in finding certainty and practicality whenever possible. Even well-intended efforts must recognize that the staff and physicians need a clear vision of the future and time to absorb and adjust to the changes.”
CHIME said it was difficult to comment on “unknown standards or other policies” that the Health IT Standards Committee might recommend for several proposed Stage 2 measures. “CHIME believes it will be important for any such standards or policies to pass a ‘practicality test,’” the comment letter read. “They should be based on realistic expectations of what motivated providers will be able to accomplish, especially with respect to entering information in a coded or structured format.”
In response to specific proposed objectives for Stage 2, CHIME’s comments included the following:
• In using clinical decision support, CHIME calls for a limited set of rules that eligible hospitals (EHs) and eligible providers (EPs) would have the flexibility to choose. “The goal at this point should not be use of a large number of CDS rules but effective use of a smaller number,” CHIME said. “EHR technology should be capable of implementing CDS rules identified as appropriate by EHs and EPs, and MU criteria should not become a ‘back door’ means for the federal government to interfere with the practice of medicine.”
• CHIME stated concerns about several Stage 2 objectives outlining percentages of visits or patient days for which patient notes must be recorded. “We believe it is premature to focus on electronic notes, largely due to a lack of physician readiness,” the comments said. “For the foreseeable future, we believe it is much more important to focus attention on (computerized provider order entry), especially with CDS, than on electronic notes.”
• In response to a proposed objective for health information exchange requiring a provider connect to at least three external providers in a primary referral network, CHIME said it was “extremely concerned…Whether there is a functioning HIE in an area is totally beyond the control of EHs and EPs. We believe that an EH or EP should be able to opt out of the HIE requirement if reasonable access to an HIE is not possible.”
The full text of CHIME’s comments on the proposed Stage 2 objectives can be found at http://www.cio-chime.org/advocacy/CHIME_Stage_2_MU_Comments-Letter_to_Seidman_February_2011.pdf.
The College of Healthcare Information Management Executives (CHIME) is an executive organization dedicated to serving chief information officers and other senior healthcare IT leaders. With more than 1,400 CIO members and over 70 healthcare IT vendors and professional services firms, CHIME provides a highly interactive, trusted environment enabling senior professional and industry leaders to collaborate; exchange best practices; address professional development needs; and advocate the effective use of information management to improve the health and healthcare in the communities they serve. For more information, please visit www.cio-chime.org.
Updated: 2/18/2011 9:43:02 AM